TMIT 51: Why We’re Done Having Kids (for Now)
Some conversations in a marriage are beautifully straightforward. Deciding when your family is complete is not one of them.
This week, we are wading into a vulnerable—and sometimes confusing—space. In the years since our third child was born, the decision to stop having kids hasn’t been a neatly checked-off box. Instead, it’s been a winding series of conversations and a delicate dance between the head and the heart. For Danielle, reaching a place of "acceptance" about stopping at three hasn't always equated to "happiness," which has been one of the hardest parts of this journey for Greg to navigate.
To help make sense of the baby-planning complexity, we dive into the fascinating, and often surprising, science of family size:
- The Global Shift: How global fertility rates have steadily slid to historic lows (with the US now sitting at a record low of about 1.6 births per woman).
- The First-Child Paradox: The sociological research showing how life satisfaction reliably spikes when you get married and have your first child, but often experiences a dip as the logistical complexity of multiple children sets in (with three kids statistically hitting the bottom of the curve).
- The 4+ Kid Phenomenon: The surprising data showing that for families who cross the threshold into four or more children, life satisfaction actually shoots back up—perhaps proving that surrendering to the chaos has its own secret rewards.
This is not an episode where we share best practices or pretend to have a perfect formula. There is no manual for knowing exactly when your family is complete. Instead, it’s a raw, honest look at the biological clock, the physical toll of pregnancy, taking "one for the team," and how we are choosing to "live the questions." We are choosing to keep talking, stay open and curious, and trust the Universe with what comes next.
Listen to TMIT 51 wherever you get your podcasts.
0:00 OK, so question for you, how many children do you think leads to peak happiness, Peak's life satisfaction? Well, I think a lot about like the two pizza team from Jeff Bezos from it. You're gonna. Make this into a long answer. I think like if you need, you know, like in general, like if you need a team, if you have a team that you can't feed with, with two pizzas, that's too big, right. So I think probably like, let's start with what it what unhappiness looks like and it's probably something bigger than that. So then you know, what feels like, what feels like a team is probably more than one and less than eight children.
0:49 So it's probably the average of that. It's probably 3 or 4. Interesting. Well, I think that you know, jury's still out because there has been some research done on this, but it's not necessarily easily duplicated. But the the most widely cited 5 year study that came out of Australia about this actually found that parents with four or more children have the highest life satisfaction. So while they often reported higher stress day-to-day, they had higher meaning, more purpose and long term life satisfaction, as well as stronger support systems that the researchers believe dramatically changed outcomes for them. Yeah.
1:35 What is it measured over? Like a? Five years, I guess the researchers expected that parents with massive families would be less happy. Actually, from what I could find is that three kids is actually the least happy state, believe it or not. So what it sounds like is that there's this U shape in parental happiness. So people that have one child are meaningfully more happy than people that have zero children. So I guess what I understood it to be is that single is less happy than you get more happy when you get married and then you get even happier when you have one child, but then you it starts to dip after you have two and then 3 is that nadir, that bottom point? And then four or more is where this life satisfaction seems to increase.
2:27 That's really interesting. Yeah. Just I'm curious about this Anyway, are you, are you bringing this to me to, to, to ask me to have another child with, with science? Not currently, no. No. Not currently, no. I just think it's interesting. Like there's definitely, you know, the whole trad wife phenomenon. And I think Elon Musk has really contributed to this as well. There's definitely this idea of more kids equals better. More kids equals higher status, right? And we're not having any more kids, No, at least not out of my body and at least not in the near future, right? And so I just wanted to talk about that today.
3:07 So maybe we should go back to the beginning. Yeah, where do you want to? Start remember that Christmas where we had we spent it with some family. It was the first Christmas after we got married and I was like Greg, I am so not ready to have children. I do remember that. And then what happened? And then you change your mind pretty quickly. Like 3 weeks later, yeah. And I was like Greg, I'm ready to have a baby. Well, at least I'm ready to be off birth control. Mm Hmm. I remember I still have a little bit of scar tissue from not you changing your mind, but just from me not realizing like I didn't play back the limiting factor in our family plans, right? So the limiting factor in what we wanted, which was multiple children, ideally 3 or more, was like the age timeline that we were working against.
4:06 And in order to have babies every two years, like starting when you were 30 made sense. But I sitting there at 31 was like, I'm still pretty young to be a dad. Like I've got a couple of years before I need to be a dad. But I didn't think about the timeline that needed to to work from like a just a genetics and you know. Whatever and the gestational periods. Well, not yeah, not even gestational periods, but just like your your ideal window, right. And I think that a lot of I've, I've spoken with a lot of younger people recently that said that their partner wasn't ready. And I'm like, how old is your partner? And it's usually a guy and he's like, and she's like 27 or 28. I'm like, the best thing you can do is not talk about it because in my experience, one day they will come to you and be like, OK, it's time.
5:07 And you know, there's, that's just you counting down the days until that happens. And once they say it's time, you don't really have a say in the matter because you, you, you got to, you got to move forward with that plan. OK. Does that make sense? So the woman drives. Also, that's just that biological clock is a real, real thing. Yeah, well, I don't know. I think this is a pretty common thing, but as soon as I went off birth control, I had this feeling that I wanted to get off birth control and just kind of see what happens. But then as soon as I went off birth control, I was like, must have baby, must have baby, right? Bingo. And that's actually the thing that I named to somebody recently is I said birth control is this trap that keeps women thinking that they're pregnant and so they don't want babies.
5:53 But once they go off, their clock starts ticking and it's like, hey, guess what time it is? It's baby time. Maybe we should be so flippant, 'cause I don't know the data on that. However, that was certainly my experience, like 100%. And so then we got Winston, right? Because I was like, if we're going to be in this try to have baby thing, I want a baby immediately. And that really worked for us, right? And so we got pregnant with Hunter pretty shortly thereafter. And then what do you think in thinking about having Jade? Yeah, I think we were on the same page about it being time. Is that right? I'm. I'm still stuck on this.
6:34 I'm sorry. I'm still stuck on this idea of a pill or whatever it is creating this psychological and biological effect that makes women who are on birth control think that they are pregnant well. You mean physically? It tricks their bodies into thinking they're pregnant. That's why they don't get a period. Exactly. We're and which means that they're living their life in this, what I would call this the latter half of their cycle, as opposed to like the very happy and full ovulatory phase, which is extremely outgoing. Yeah, there's something wrong with that. Thanks, I agree, sucks.
7:21 There's something wrong with that. Like, I feel badly that we're pushing our girls to just suppress that ovulatory phase. That is where they derive so much pleasure, energy and delight, you know, outward and inward. Yeah, no, I mean, I really hope that neither of our girls ever have to go on hormonal birth control, right. So. OK, Yeah, yeah, All right. I'm this is something for another day. Maybe. My mind is, I've, I've thought about this a bit and I've talked about it a little bit, but my mind is kind of blown by by this idea that like so many people don't want to have babies because they're, they're not awake to the idea. That they. Yeah.
8:02 I don't know. I think fewer people want to have babies today than ever. I don't. I can't say for sure that that's because of hormonal birth control, but maybe perhaps it is. I mean, certainly right now in the US the fertility rate for per woman is about 1.6 children, which is well below the replacement rate of 2.1. But globally, the fertility rate has fallen from five children per woman in 1950 to 2.3 today. 5. 5. How is that even possible? That's an average. Yeah, yeah. Oh my God, yeah, we're really starting to. I mean, I'm actually more shocked by the 2.2 to 2.3 today globally. Like we have more children in our family than the average in the world.
8:51 That's that's actually surprising to me. I I wonder like how much of this is the spacing between children caused by women going back on birth control after pregnancy? I don't know. We are, we have really left the land of data though when you ask these questions into the into the land of conjecture. Certainly Anyway, we're really, I don't, I don't necessarily think that spacing is the, I think it's delaying the start. So for sure, births among women under the age 35 have fallen significantly in the US, and births of from women ages 40 to 45 have grown.
9:35 Sure. Yeah, that makes sense. That part definitely makes sense. I mean, I, I, you know, I feel so much younger at 41 than I, I found my parents looking and feeling at 41. So this. Is part of the challenge that we have sat with for the past number of years is that so? I had Maverick when I was 35. He was a surprise, by the way. We were hoping to have three, but we were not planning for a third one that quickly. But I'm so glad it worked out. It worked out great, but I would say after Maverick, it's been a journey and we haven't always been on the same page. There have been days, weeks, months where it has been challenging to not be on the same page because we usually are right. Right now we are.
10:27 Interestingly, I wouldn't say months. I think that for you. I know 'cause I tracked it at one point. You're right. Months if you string them together. String them together but it always followed the same cycle and so I was able to just sit there and it instead of being like is this what we really need? I was just like this is showing up again this. Too shall pass. Yeah, I would say there was a good six month stretch there maybe two years ago. Now that more days than not I wanted to be pregnant. I don't even want to tell you that I wanted to have a fourth child. Like my body and my mind just really wanted to be pregnant, which is a crazy thing honestly.
11:12 It's not that crazy if you think about like how it should work. Like I, if I was designing a human to populate this earth, I would be like, hey, once you start, make sure that during this window you want it. And then that window doesn't close, and that body needs to keep regenerating, but not enough so that it's fully healed enough so that it could have another baby. Right. Well, I definitely did not fully heal between children, that's for sure. And that actually goes back to one of your primary reasons for us not having any more kids. Correct. And that's the that's the thing that I was fighting nature, you know, against. I was fighting against nature with this idea that I didn't want for you to have to go through this with your body again. And nature was like, hey, Are you ready yet? Can you talk a little bit more about that though? Because to be quite honest, I think that I really was in a pregnancy, breastfeeding malaise for a while. And I don't know that I was.
12:12 I, I actually think that you were more aware of what my body needed than I was. Yeah. Which is kind of funny because usually you have the best memory when it comes to these sorts of things. But yeah, but when you're not sleeping and like you got all the feel good. Ones of the nurse Another beautiful design of our of our human bodies is that you, like you, forgot all of the pain and suffering that you went through with each child, more so than the last, right? Yeah, by the third pregnancy, my body was starting to fall apart for sure. Yeah. It was and I and I saw that first hand and I was like, yo, like let's let's not put you through that again.
12:54 Like, not that you're going to die or anything, but like, this is this is going to take away so much joy of what you currently have if you do it again. And the people around you are going to be missing the person that is here. Yeah, because of what you will need to put your body through. Right, Yeah, being a mom to Hunter especially was really hard when I was pregnant with Maverick. She needed, I feel like Jade was so little that so she was, you know, only about a year when I got pregnant with Maverick and I could I could still give her enough. I don't think I breastfed her for as long as I probably would have otherwise. But other than that, I feel like I could support her needs, her waking up at 4:00 AM needs.
13:37 But it was really hard to be there for Hunter when I was pregnant with Maverick. I mean, it's hard to be there for Maverick now and I don't even have more kids like that, you know, kind of 3-4 year old age is pretty tough. But I guess what ultimately has given me peace for for now around not having more kids is that you asked me at one point when I was sobbing on the floor of our bedroom around how I really wanted to be pregnant when enough would be enough. And I didn't have an answer for you. And I still don't have an answer for you. And I think that that is, that's the reason why for, for us 3 has to be enough because it wasn't a feeling like, oh, just one more.
14:23 Right. It was like no, I just want to keep doing this until my body literally shuts down. Do. You remember that time that I was on the phone with an investor and we were working on a deal and he's like in the hospital basically. We're very close to it. And his wife is pregnant with his 5th. And I knew that he had four kids, but he didn't tell me that she was pregnant with the 5th And that like it was imminent any day now. And I remember him saying to me, I said, wow, like you've got such a big family. Like, isn't that beautiful? And he's like, Greg, don't, don't make the same mistakes that I. Do yeah.
15:03 I, I don't know that there's ever I have we have we have one friend. They have three children. The the the youngest is Hunter's age. They're they're older now. And she just has the gift of like, she's like, as soon as I had her, our last daughter, like I was just done. I knew that our family was complete. And I envy that. I really do. I'm like, I have never had that feeling. I am at peace with having three and I, you know, pack 3 lunches every day and I fill up 3 water bottles and I'm just like, yeah, this is like a beautiful design. Like I love the the three, you know, but I would be lying if I said that I was 100% happy about it.
15:46 But I'm at I'm at peace with it. I could be a 2 pizza team by myself. I know I. Was going to say it's a bad this whole 2 pizza thing is bad for us because we eat so much. We eat so much, but. It's a, it's across everything like we are, we're definitely gluttonous a little bit when it comes to like wanting more out of, you know, this wanting, you know, a second serving of that wanting like our kids to be able to do this in addition to all the other things that they're doing. Like it's, it's something that drives us, but it's also a little bit of a character flaw, you know, that we can't just sit with enough is enough. Right. We're maximizers, not satisficers in a lot of.
16:27 Aspects refrigerator look at like you look at you know everything that we do and it's not surprising like it is OK that you struggled with this like that is not abnormal. It fits the profile. Right. Well, I guess I always said to myself, I want to have a third kid because I don't think I can be a perfectionist with three. And that has been true for sure, for sure, for sure. But also based on like the research that I'm seeing, and this is not me trying to have a fourth kid, but just based on the research that I'm seeing, I do see that. That's why the life satisfaction increases because you like physically can't, as you have more children, be a perfectionist, right? And so you have to focus on the longer term, have to focus on the meaning and the support structures that exist when you have a large family meaning.
17:15 You can't do it all. You know, I the other thing I think about is this whole Google, you know, how they were supposed to have that 10% time, meaning 10% that they're allowed to have like just do whatever they want and work on creative projects. Yeah, shouldn't say do whatever you want 10% time, meaning like focus on creative projects. I also think back to like Hugh Jackman always saying, you know, just give 80% in your workouts 'cause you just leaving a little bit on the table. So whatever it is, I, I think of these best practices and I think that is what we have done. And as you know, one of my 1, I don't feel pulled to do too many things in life. I'm not like someone that has these grand callings really. But one thing I really truly feel called to do is to foster. And so as as you know, but just sharing with everyone that like our agreement is that we're stopping with three, but that we will foster when the time is right. Yeah, unless caveat, they make it possible to have a baby in a test tube until the age of five.
18:23 I'd take that baby out and I'd be like, this is great, join the team. Tell him set the floor, character sets the ceiling. Let's go if. We could program that child and not have to take care of it. Ages 0 through 5. I would be totally on board. Yeah, we're almost there. Maverick's almost 5. He's 4 1/2. Every day is a struggle. Every day is struggle. But he's going to get there one day at a time. We're to keep him alive and we're going to be there well. When you have a child that needs as much as you're first, but there's two others around. Oh. It's really. Really if anybody has successfully navigated this like 4 to 6 year old boy transition, especially like youngest boy, please please let us know. We're taking, we're taking all tips and suggestions right now. And if you want one also for a week. If you want to borrow 1, see.
19:10 Let's see what it's like, yeah? It's totally open e-mail. Emails are open VMS. You know where to find us. Yeah. So one other thing. At some point during my postpartum malaise, I don't, I don't mean to say it in a bad way, 'cause I think I was clear headed about this. You made a very clear move to not have any more children. With your encouragement. Yeah, about how old was Maverick when you got a vasectomy? Maybe like one 1 1/2? So I was still nursing.
19:53 You're still nursing. You were sleeping again. I do remember that. And yeah, I think there were, you know, we had just moved into this house maybe like maybe I guess a a year prior and we had met a bunch of people in the neighborhood and some of them were older and everybody was just like vasectomy. Everybody that we met and I was like, cool, sign me up. And you said like, I'm never going on birth control. Again, yes, I did. And you were like, you're going to have to take this one for the team. Yes. And that was the that was the way it flowed. You know, you said, hey, I'm not doing this. This is the thing that you're going to do. And I was like, OK, cool, let's go.
20:34 Yeah, I think you had an easier time with it than a lot of men, from what I understand from Bravo Television, honestly. I think, you know, if you're on Bravo and you have a segment about getting a vasectomy, you're going to draw it out a little. Bit like Kevin Hall about it. Have you convinced any other men you know to get a vasectomy? No. No. No, but the push backs that I get are like, what if they miss? We're like, I, I never want to mess with anything down there. And I'm like, yeah, but like, this is a really positive thing that you could do for your family and actually becomes the gift that keeps on giving. Well, it was the thing that as we were kind of going through, I was going through these ups and downs and we were having these conversations.
21:28 It definitely did put a block on things, right? I couldn't even like, dare I sneakily get pregnant, right? Yeah. I hate to think that I ever would, but exactly. Yeah. And that was that. Was clear to me. Yeah, but so you feel good about that decision I. Mean every single day. Yeah, literally. The gift that keeps on giving. Just that freedom. Yeah. Yeah. All right. Pro Vasectomy. Very pro, Very pro. And so here we are. We're done having kids for now. But I do look forward to the time, which is not right now 'cause we're still in the thick of it. But I do look forward to the time when we can broach fostering.
22:11 Yeah, more than just puppies. Fostering humans. That's right. That's right. Yeah, OK, OK. Anything you'd like to add? 3 feels great to me. So despite what the what the research says, 3 feels like the right spot for us. Yeah. I mean, given all the other things that we want to do. In life, climbing our own mountains, traveling. And at this point, I think that ship has sailed anyway, right? Because like the spacing that we have is brilliant. I love it. Right. It's a blessing and a curse for sure. Like I think that if we only had had two kids now, we could have gotten on board with, you know, having a five year gap and then having two more.
22:54 Yeah, sure. So it works for us. No, it works for us. It feels pretty great. It does, and we reserve the right to change our minds. Yes, so we're done having kids for now. Might have a. Five year old, maybe 2-5 year olds that are twins that we don't need to adopt, just grow them in a lab. You're nuts. Love you, goosey. Love you, goosey.